Everybody's laughin' in my mindRumours spreadin' 'bout this other guyDo you do what you did when you did with me?Does he love you the way I can?Did you forget all the plans that you made with me?'Cause, baby, I didn't
That should be me, holdin' your handThat should be me, makin' you laughThat should be me, this is so sadThat should be me, that should be me
That should be me, feelin' your kissThat should be me, buyin' you giftsThis is so wrong, I can't go on'Til you believe that that should be meThat should be me
You said, you needed a little time from my mistakesIt's funny how you used that time to have me replacedDid you think that I wouldn't see you out at the movies?What you doin' to me?You're taking him where we used to goNow if you're trying to break my heartIt's workin', 'cause you know that
That should be me, holdin' your handThat should be me, makin' you laughThat should be me, this is so sadThat should be me, that should be me
That should be me, feelin' your kissThat should be me, buyin' you giftsThis is so wrong, I can't go on'Til you believe that that should be me
I need to know should I fight for loveOr disarm, it's getting harder to shieldThis pain in my heart
Oh, that should be me, holdin' your handThat should be me, makin' you laughThat should be me, this is so sadThat should be me, that should be me
That should be me, feelin' your kissThat should be me, buyin' you giftsThis is so wrong, I can't go on'Til you believe that that should be me
Holding your hand (that should be me)The one making you laugh, oh baby, ohThat should be me, yeahThat should be me, giving you flowersThat should be me, talking for hoursThat should be me, that should be me (that should be me)
Never should have let you goI never should have let you go, oh, oh (that should be me)Never should have let you go, oohWoah, (that should be me)Never should have let you go (yeah, yeah, yeah)I never should have let you go, oh